The Overcooked Generalisation Challenge

Constantin Ruhdorfer, Matteo Bortoletto, Anna Penzkofer, Andreas Bulling·June 25, 2024

Summary

The Overcooked Generalisation Challenge (OGC) is a novel benchmark introduced to assess zero-shot cooperation in AI agents, using the Overcooked-AI environment. It evaluates agents' adaptability to new layouts and partners, focusing on generalization, unlike previous work. The OGC employs dual curriculum design methods and is built on a GPU-accelerated platform. Current DCD algorithms and network architectures struggle in this context, indicating a need for research on generalization for human-AI collaboration. The study highlights PAIRED with a SoftMoE module as a top performer, and the OGC contributes a platform for evaluating generalization in cooperative multi-agent reinforcement learning, with a focus on unsupervised environment design and human-AI cooperation. The research also explores various DCD algorithms, network architectures, and their limitations in the challenging Overcooked environment.

Key findings

7

Paper digest

What problem does the paper attempt to solve? Is this a new problem?

The paper introduces the Overcooked Generalisation Challenge (OGC) to address the issue of zero-shot cooperation abilities of agents when faced with novel partners and levels in the Overcooked-AI environment . This challenge aims to study the generalization abilities required for real-world human-AI cooperation, which contrasts previous work that focused on training and evaluating cooperating agents on the same level only . The problem of zero-shot cooperation in unfamiliar environments is not entirely new, but the OGC presents a novel benchmark specifically designed to push the boundaries of human-AI cooperation by emphasizing generalization capabilities .


What scientific hypothesis does this paper seek to validate?

This paper aims to validate the scientific hypothesis related to zero-shot cooperation in multi-agent reinforcement learning (MARL) environments, specifically focusing on human-AI collaboration . The research explores the impact of cross-level generalization for zero-shot cooperation and provides the necessary tools to train and evaluate agents capable of coordinating in previously unknown physical spaces and with novel partners . The study delves into decentralized under-specified partially observable Markov decision processes (Dec-UPOMDP) with shared rewards to formalize the cooperative multi-agent setting .


What new ideas, methods, or models does the paper propose? What are the characteristics and advantages compared to previous methods?

The paper "The Overcooked Generalisation Challenge" proposes several innovative ideas, methods, and models related to multi-agent reinforcement learning (MARL) and human-AI collaboration . Here are some key points from the paper:

  1. Overcooked Generalisation Challenge (OGC): The paper introduces the OGC as a generalisation challenge focusing on cooperation in MARL in out-of-distribution test levels. It is the first unsupervised design MARL environment and is more challenging than previous environments used in research on unsupervised experience distillation (UED) and dynamic curriculum distillation (DCD) .

  2. Zero-Shot Cooperation Benchmark: The OGC serves as a zero-shot cooperation benchmark for general agents, establishing a link between generalisation and zero-shot coordination. It provides tools to train and evaluate agents capable of coordinating in previously unknown physical spaces and with novel partners .

  3. Evaluation Scenarios: The paper suggests evaluating agents in scenarios that are challenging for self-play agents, including zero-shot cooperation with strongly-biased agents and asymmetric advantages. It emphasizes the importance of studying zero-shot coordination via generalising across layouts and reasoning about other agents to achieve cooperation capabilities onI appreciate your question, but I need more specific details or context to provide a relevant analysis. Could you please provide me with the title of the paper or a brief summary of its content? The paper "The Overcooked Generalisation Challenge" introduces several key characteristics and advantages compared to previous methods in the field of multi-agent reinforcement learning (MARL) and human-AI collaboration .

  4. Novel Benchmark Challenge: The Overcooked Generalisation Challenge (OGC) presents a novel benchmark where agents are required to cooperate with new partners in unseen layouts, focusing on zero-shot cooperation abilities . This challenge is designed to assess agents' generalization capabilities in out-of-distribution test levels, which is a significant advancement compared to previous benchmarks that evaluated agents only on the same level .

  5. Open-Source Environment: The paper provides OvercookedUED, an open-source environment integrated into minimax, leveraging hardware acceleration with JAX . This environment allows for the training and evaluation of agents using state-of-the-art dynamic curriculum distillation (DCD) algorithms, enhancing the scalability and generalizability of the training process .

  6. Struggles of Current Algorithms: The study shows that current DCD algorithms face challenges in producing effective policies in the OGC, even when combined with recent network architectures optimized for scalability and generalization . This highlights the need for further research and development to enhance the performance of algorithms in complex cooperation scenarios .

  7. Zero-Shot Cooperation Benchmark: The OGC serves as a zero-shot cooperation benchmark, enabling the evaluation of agents' abilities to coordinate in previously unknown physical spaces with diverse partners . This benchmark establishes a crucial link between generalization and zero-shot coordination, pushing the boundaries of real-world human-AI cooperation research .

  8. Future Directions: The paper acknowledges limitations such as the artificial restriction on layout sizes and the importance of reasoning about other agents to achieve zero-shot cooperation capabilities in unknown layouts . Future work could explore natural representations of scenes and further investigate the role of reasoning about other agents in unexplored environments .

In summary, the Overcooked Generalisation Challenge introduces a groundbreaking benchmark for evaluating zero-shot cooperation abilities in MARL, providing an open-source environment, highlighting the struggles of current algorithms, and paving the way for future research in human-AI collaboration and generalization in complex cooperative scenarios .


Do any related researches exist? Who are the noteworthy researchers on this topic in this field?What is the key to the solution mentioned in the paper?

Several related research papers exist in the field of human-robot interaction and cooperation. Noteworthy researchers in this field include Rohan Choudhury, Gokul Swamy, Dylan Hadfield-Menell, Anca D. Dragan, David G. Rand, Martin A. Nowak, Liza Vizmathy, Katarina Begus, Gunther Knoblich, György Gergely, Arianna Curioni, Stefanos Nikolaidis, Julie Shah, Dorsa Sadigh, Shankar Sastry, Sanjit A. Seshia, Micah Carroll, and many others .

The key to the solution mentioned in the paper "The Overcooked Generalisation Challenge" involves introducing a novel benchmark challenge where agents cooperate with novel partners in previously unseen layouts, providing an open-source environment called OvercookedUED for state-of-the-art DCD algorithms, and benchmarking the environment by training agents with common DCD algorithms to assess zero-shot cooperation performance with a diverse population of partners .


How were the experiments in the paper designed?

The experiments in the paper were designed to introduce the Overcooked Generalisation Challenge (OGC), which focuses on studying agents' zero-shot cooperation abilities when faced with novel partners and levels in the Overcooked-AI environment. The OGC is the first benchmark that aims to assess the generalization abilities required for real-world human-AI cooperation . The challenge interfaces with state-of-the-art dual curriculum design (DCD) methods to generate auto-curricula for training general agents in Overcooked, making it the first cooperative multi-agent environment specifically designed for DCD methods and benchmarked with state-of-the-art methods . The experiments aimed to push the boundaries of real-world human-AI cooperation by enabling the research community to study the impact of generalization on cooperating agents .


What is the dataset used for quantitative evaluation? Is the code open source?

The dataset used for quantitative evaluation in the study is the Overcooked Generalisation Challenge dataset . The code associated with the Overcooked adaption is open source and can be accessed under the Apache License 2.0 via the GitHub repository: https://github.com/FLAIROx/JaxMARL .


Do the experiments and results in the paper provide good support for the scientific hypotheses that need to be verified? Please analyze.

The experiments and results presented in the paper provide substantial support for the scientific hypotheses that needed verification. The Overcooked Generalisation Challenge (OGC) introduced in the paper focuses on zero-shot cooperation in Multi-Agent Reinforcement Learning (MARL) in out-of-distribution test levels, making it significantly more challenging than previous environments commonly used in research . The paper establishes a link between generalization and zero-shot coordination, addressing the need for agents capable of coordinating in previously unknown physical spaces and with novel partners . The results of the experiments, such as the mean episode rewards for different methods and the performance of SoftMoE-LSTM paired with an FCP population, demonstrate the effectiveness of the proposed challenge in evaluating zero-shot coordination capabilities . Additionally, the paper acknowledges the limitations of the challenge, highlighting areas for future research to explore, such as reasoning about other agents in unexplored environments .


What are the contributions of this paper?

The paper makes several contributions, including:

  • Proposing a standardized performance evaluation protocol for cooperative multi-agent reinforcement learning .
  • Introducing structured state space models for in-context reinforcement learning .
  • Discussing the utility of model learning in human-robot interaction .
  • Exploring human cooperation and collaboration with robots .
  • Presenting a study on overfitting in deep reinforcement learning .
  • Addressing the topic of human-ai collaboration and coordination .
  • Investigating automated curriculum learning for neural networks .
  • Introducing a diverse suite of scalable reinforcement learning environments in JAX .
  • Discussing the use of large language models with embodied environments via reinforcement learning .
  • Exploring the concept of maximum entropy population-based training for zero-shot human-ai coordination .

What work can be continued in depth?

Work that can be continued in depth typically involves projects or tasks that require further analysis, research, or development. This could include scientific research, academic studies, technological advancements, creative projects, business strategies, and more. By delving deeper into these areas, one can uncover new insights, make improvements, and achieve greater levels of success or innovation.

Tables

1

Introduction
Background
Overview of Overcooked-AI environment
Importance of zero-shot cooperation in AI agents
Limitations of previous cooperative multi-agent research
Objective
Introduce the OGC's purpose
Assess generalization in AI agents
Encourage research on human-AI collaboration
Methodology
Data Collection
Overcooked-AI environment setup
Dual curriculum design (DCD) methods
GPU-accelerated platform implementation
Data Preprocessing
Adaptation to new layouts and partners
Unsupervised environment design process
Evaluation of agent-agent interactions
Algorithms and Network Architectures
Current Approaches
Analysis of DCD algorithms
Challenges faced by existing models
PAIRED with SoftMoE Module
Performance of PAIRED in OGC
SoftMoE module contribution to generalization
Evaluation
Performance metrics for cooperative reinforcement learning
Comparison of different models in the OGC
Human-AI cooperation analysis
Limitations and Future Directions
Current DCD algorithms' shortcomings
Opportunities for research in human-AI collaboration
OGC as a platform for future advancements
Conclusion
Summary of OGC's impact on the field
Importance of the benchmark for cooperative AI development
Call to action for researchers to address generalization in Overcooked environment.
Basic info
papers
machine learning
artificial intelligence
multiagent systems
Advanced features
Insights
What is the Overcooked Generalisation Challenge (OGC) used for?
What is the current performance challenge faced by DCD algorithms and network architectures in the Overcooked-AI environment?
Which platform does the OGC utilize for its operations?
How does the OGC differ from previous work in the field of AI agent cooperation?

The Overcooked Generalisation Challenge

Constantin Ruhdorfer, Matteo Bortoletto, Anna Penzkofer, Andreas Bulling·June 25, 2024

Summary

The Overcooked Generalisation Challenge (OGC) is a novel benchmark introduced to assess zero-shot cooperation in AI agents, using the Overcooked-AI environment. It evaluates agents' adaptability to new layouts and partners, focusing on generalization, unlike previous work. The OGC employs dual curriculum design methods and is built on a GPU-accelerated platform. Current DCD algorithms and network architectures struggle in this context, indicating a need for research on generalization for human-AI collaboration. The study highlights PAIRED with a SoftMoE module as a top performer, and the OGC contributes a platform for evaluating generalization in cooperative multi-agent reinforcement learning, with a focus on unsupervised environment design and human-AI cooperation. The research also explores various DCD algorithms, network architectures, and their limitations in the challenging Overcooked environment.
Mind map
SoftMoE module contribution to generalization
Performance of PAIRED in OGC
Challenges faced by existing models
Analysis of DCD algorithms
PAIRED with SoftMoE Module
Current Approaches
Evaluation of agent-agent interactions
Unsupervised environment design process
Adaptation to new layouts and partners
GPU-accelerated platform implementation
Dual curriculum design (DCD) methods
Overcooked-AI environment setup
Encourage research on human-AI collaboration
Assess generalization in AI agents
Introduce the OGC's purpose
Limitations of previous cooperative multi-agent research
Importance of zero-shot cooperation in AI agents
Overview of Overcooked-AI environment
Call to action for researchers to address generalization in Overcooked environment.
Importance of the benchmark for cooperative AI development
Summary of OGC's impact on the field
OGC as a platform for future advancements
Opportunities for research in human-AI collaboration
Current DCD algorithms' shortcomings
Human-AI cooperation analysis
Comparison of different models in the OGC
Performance metrics for cooperative reinforcement learning
Algorithms and Network Architectures
Data Preprocessing
Data Collection
Objective
Background
Conclusion
Limitations and Future Directions
Evaluation
Methodology
Introduction
Outline
Introduction
Background
Overview of Overcooked-AI environment
Importance of zero-shot cooperation in AI agents
Limitations of previous cooperative multi-agent research
Objective
Introduce the OGC's purpose
Assess generalization in AI agents
Encourage research on human-AI collaboration
Methodology
Data Collection
Overcooked-AI environment setup
Dual curriculum design (DCD) methods
GPU-accelerated platform implementation
Data Preprocessing
Adaptation to new layouts and partners
Unsupervised environment design process
Evaluation of agent-agent interactions
Algorithms and Network Architectures
Current Approaches
Analysis of DCD algorithms
Challenges faced by existing models
PAIRED with SoftMoE Module
Performance of PAIRED in OGC
SoftMoE module contribution to generalization
Evaluation
Performance metrics for cooperative reinforcement learning
Comparison of different models in the OGC
Human-AI cooperation analysis
Limitations and Future Directions
Current DCD algorithms' shortcomings
Opportunities for research in human-AI collaboration
OGC as a platform for future advancements
Conclusion
Summary of OGC's impact on the field
Importance of the benchmark for cooperative AI development
Call to action for researchers to address generalization in Overcooked environment.
Key findings
7

Paper digest

What problem does the paper attempt to solve? Is this a new problem?

The paper introduces the Overcooked Generalisation Challenge (OGC) to address the issue of zero-shot cooperation abilities of agents when faced with novel partners and levels in the Overcooked-AI environment . This challenge aims to study the generalization abilities required for real-world human-AI cooperation, which contrasts previous work that focused on training and evaluating cooperating agents on the same level only . The problem of zero-shot cooperation in unfamiliar environments is not entirely new, but the OGC presents a novel benchmark specifically designed to push the boundaries of human-AI cooperation by emphasizing generalization capabilities .


What scientific hypothesis does this paper seek to validate?

This paper aims to validate the scientific hypothesis related to zero-shot cooperation in multi-agent reinforcement learning (MARL) environments, specifically focusing on human-AI collaboration . The research explores the impact of cross-level generalization for zero-shot cooperation and provides the necessary tools to train and evaluate agents capable of coordinating in previously unknown physical spaces and with novel partners . The study delves into decentralized under-specified partially observable Markov decision processes (Dec-UPOMDP) with shared rewards to formalize the cooperative multi-agent setting .


What new ideas, methods, or models does the paper propose? What are the characteristics and advantages compared to previous methods?

The paper "The Overcooked Generalisation Challenge" proposes several innovative ideas, methods, and models related to multi-agent reinforcement learning (MARL) and human-AI collaboration . Here are some key points from the paper:

  1. Overcooked Generalisation Challenge (OGC): The paper introduces the OGC as a generalisation challenge focusing on cooperation in MARL in out-of-distribution test levels. It is the first unsupervised design MARL environment and is more challenging than previous environments used in research on unsupervised experience distillation (UED) and dynamic curriculum distillation (DCD) .

  2. Zero-Shot Cooperation Benchmark: The OGC serves as a zero-shot cooperation benchmark for general agents, establishing a link between generalisation and zero-shot coordination. It provides tools to train and evaluate agents capable of coordinating in previously unknown physical spaces and with novel partners .

  3. Evaluation Scenarios: The paper suggests evaluating agents in scenarios that are challenging for self-play agents, including zero-shot cooperation with strongly-biased agents and asymmetric advantages. It emphasizes the importance of studying zero-shot coordination via generalising across layouts and reasoning about other agents to achieve cooperation capabilities onI appreciate your question, but I need more specific details or context to provide a relevant analysis. Could you please provide me with the title of the paper or a brief summary of its content? The paper "The Overcooked Generalisation Challenge" introduces several key characteristics and advantages compared to previous methods in the field of multi-agent reinforcement learning (MARL) and human-AI collaboration .

  4. Novel Benchmark Challenge: The Overcooked Generalisation Challenge (OGC) presents a novel benchmark where agents are required to cooperate with new partners in unseen layouts, focusing on zero-shot cooperation abilities . This challenge is designed to assess agents' generalization capabilities in out-of-distribution test levels, which is a significant advancement compared to previous benchmarks that evaluated agents only on the same level .

  5. Open-Source Environment: The paper provides OvercookedUED, an open-source environment integrated into minimax, leveraging hardware acceleration with JAX . This environment allows for the training and evaluation of agents using state-of-the-art dynamic curriculum distillation (DCD) algorithms, enhancing the scalability and generalizability of the training process .

  6. Struggles of Current Algorithms: The study shows that current DCD algorithms face challenges in producing effective policies in the OGC, even when combined with recent network architectures optimized for scalability and generalization . This highlights the need for further research and development to enhance the performance of algorithms in complex cooperation scenarios .

  7. Zero-Shot Cooperation Benchmark: The OGC serves as a zero-shot cooperation benchmark, enabling the evaluation of agents' abilities to coordinate in previously unknown physical spaces with diverse partners . This benchmark establishes a crucial link between generalization and zero-shot coordination, pushing the boundaries of real-world human-AI cooperation research .

  8. Future Directions: The paper acknowledges limitations such as the artificial restriction on layout sizes and the importance of reasoning about other agents to achieve zero-shot cooperation capabilities in unknown layouts . Future work could explore natural representations of scenes and further investigate the role of reasoning about other agents in unexplored environments .

In summary, the Overcooked Generalisation Challenge introduces a groundbreaking benchmark for evaluating zero-shot cooperation abilities in MARL, providing an open-source environment, highlighting the struggles of current algorithms, and paving the way for future research in human-AI collaboration and generalization in complex cooperative scenarios .


Do any related researches exist? Who are the noteworthy researchers on this topic in this field?What is the key to the solution mentioned in the paper?

Several related research papers exist in the field of human-robot interaction and cooperation. Noteworthy researchers in this field include Rohan Choudhury, Gokul Swamy, Dylan Hadfield-Menell, Anca D. Dragan, David G. Rand, Martin A. Nowak, Liza Vizmathy, Katarina Begus, Gunther Knoblich, György Gergely, Arianna Curioni, Stefanos Nikolaidis, Julie Shah, Dorsa Sadigh, Shankar Sastry, Sanjit A. Seshia, Micah Carroll, and many others .

The key to the solution mentioned in the paper "The Overcooked Generalisation Challenge" involves introducing a novel benchmark challenge where agents cooperate with novel partners in previously unseen layouts, providing an open-source environment called OvercookedUED for state-of-the-art DCD algorithms, and benchmarking the environment by training agents with common DCD algorithms to assess zero-shot cooperation performance with a diverse population of partners .


How were the experiments in the paper designed?

The experiments in the paper were designed to introduce the Overcooked Generalisation Challenge (OGC), which focuses on studying agents' zero-shot cooperation abilities when faced with novel partners and levels in the Overcooked-AI environment. The OGC is the first benchmark that aims to assess the generalization abilities required for real-world human-AI cooperation . The challenge interfaces with state-of-the-art dual curriculum design (DCD) methods to generate auto-curricula for training general agents in Overcooked, making it the first cooperative multi-agent environment specifically designed for DCD methods and benchmarked with state-of-the-art methods . The experiments aimed to push the boundaries of real-world human-AI cooperation by enabling the research community to study the impact of generalization on cooperating agents .


What is the dataset used for quantitative evaluation? Is the code open source?

The dataset used for quantitative evaluation in the study is the Overcooked Generalisation Challenge dataset . The code associated with the Overcooked adaption is open source and can be accessed under the Apache License 2.0 via the GitHub repository: https://github.com/FLAIROx/JaxMARL .


Do the experiments and results in the paper provide good support for the scientific hypotheses that need to be verified? Please analyze.

The experiments and results presented in the paper provide substantial support for the scientific hypotheses that needed verification. The Overcooked Generalisation Challenge (OGC) introduced in the paper focuses on zero-shot cooperation in Multi-Agent Reinforcement Learning (MARL) in out-of-distribution test levels, making it significantly more challenging than previous environments commonly used in research . The paper establishes a link between generalization and zero-shot coordination, addressing the need for agents capable of coordinating in previously unknown physical spaces and with novel partners . The results of the experiments, such as the mean episode rewards for different methods and the performance of SoftMoE-LSTM paired with an FCP population, demonstrate the effectiveness of the proposed challenge in evaluating zero-shot coordination capabilities . Additionally, the paper acknowledges the limitations of the challenge, highlighting areas for future research to explore, such as reasoning about other agents in unexplored environments .


What are the contributions of this paper?

The paper makes several contributions, including:

  • Proposing a standardized performance evaluation protocol for cooperative multi-agent reinforcement learning .
  • Introducing structured state space models for in-context reinforcement learning .
  • Discussing the utility of model learning in human-robot interaction .
  • Exploring human cooperation and collaboration with robots .
  • Presenting a study on overfitting in deep reinforcement learning .
  • Addressing the topic of human-ai collaboration and coordination .
  • Investigating automated curriculum learning for neural networks .
  • Introducing a diverse suite of scalable reinforcement learning environments in JAX .
  • Discussing the use of large language models with embodied environments via reinforcement learning .
  • Exploring the concept of maximum entropy population-based training for zero-shot human-ai coordination .

What work can be continued in depth?

Work that can be continued in depth typically involves projects or tasks that require further analysis, research, or development. This could include scientific research, academic studies, technological advancements, creative projects, business strategies, and more. By delving deeper into these areas, one can uncover new insights, make improvements, and achieve greater levels of success or innovation.

Tables
1
Scan the QR code to ask more questions about the paper
© 2025 Powerdrill. All rights reserved.