Infusing clinical knowledge into tokenisers for language models
Summary
Paper digest
What problem does the paper attempt to solve? Is this a new problem?
The paper aims to infuse clinical knowledge into tokenisers for language models to enhance their performance in various clinical natural language processing (NLP) tasks, such as clinical concept extraction, relation extraction, automated clinical coding, clinical phenotype identification, and clinical research article classification . This paper addresses the challenge of improving the efficiency and accuracy of language models in processing clinical text by incorporating domain-specific clinical knowledge from sources like the Unified Medical Language System (UMLS) and clinical corpora like PubMed and MIMIC-III . While the integration of clinical knowledge into tokenisers for language models is not a new concept, the specific approach and methodology outlined in this paper represent a novel contribution to the field of clinical NLP .
What scientific hypothesis does this paper seek to validate?
This paper aims to validate the scientific hypothesis that integrating domain-specific knowledge into tokenisers for language models, specifically through the K-Tokeniser framework, enhances the performance of clinical text processing tasks . The study introduces K-Tokeniser, which leverages semantic types of domain concepts like drugs or diseases to generate global representations of tokens during the initialisation stage. This approach aims to improve semantic-based tokenisation by selecting optimal global token representations based on localised context at the training or inference stage . The paper conducts experiments using transformer-based language models on real-world datasets to evaluate K-Tokeniser in various clinical text analytics tasks, including clinical concept and relation extraction, automated clinical coding, clinical phenotype identification, and clinical research article classification. The results demonstrate consistent improvements over existing models, particularly showing significant enhancements in automated clinical coding tasks and quicker convergence of language models with reduced training data requirements .
What new ideas, methods, or models does the paper propose? What are the characteristics and advantages compared to previous methods?
The paper "Infusing clinical knowledge into tokenisers for language models" introduces a novel knowledge-enhanced tokenisation mechanism called K-Tokeniser for clinical text processing . This tokeniser utilises global representations of tokens based on semantic types of domain concepts, such as drugs or diseases, from a domain ontology like the Unified Medical Language System (UMLS) or the training data of the task-related corpus . The K-Tokeniser is designed to improve clinical Natural Language Processing (NLP) tasks by selecting optimal global token representations based on semantic categories .
One key aspect of the paper is the methodology used to evaluate the K-Tokeniser. The study involves conducting a comprehensive set of experiments on four real-world datasets to assess the performance of the K-Tokeniser in various clinical text analytics tasks, including clinical concept and relation extraction, automated clinical coding, clinical phenotype identification, and clinical research article classification . The results of these experiments demonstrate consistent improvements over existing models in all tasks, with a notable 13% increase in the Micro F1 score for automated clinical coding .
The paper also proposes an embedding initialisation approach to generate representations for new tokens without the need for pretraining using the new tokeniser . This approach aims to facilitate quicker convergence of language models, reducing the amount of training data required to achieve optimal performance. Specifically, the language models using the K-Tokeniser only need 50% of the training data to achieve the best performance compared to baseline tokenisers using all training data in concept extraction tasks and less than 20% of the data for automated coding tasks .
Furthermore, the study explores the correlation between word fertility and F1 scores in the context of clinical concept extraction tasks . The analysis reveals a relationship between the variation in fertility and corresponding differences in F1 scores, motivating the setting of fertility thresholds at specific values to optimize performance . This innovative approach enhances the tokenisation process in clinical NLP tasks, leading to improved accuracy and efficiency in processing clinical text data . The paper "Infusing clinical knowledge into tokenisers for language models" introduces the K-Tokeniser, a novel tokenisation mechanism for clinical text processing that offers several key characteristics and advantages over previous methods .
-
Semantic-Based Tokenisation: The K-Tokeniser utilises global representations of tokens based on semantic types of domain concepts, such as drugs or diseases, from a domain ontology like the Unified Medical Language System (UMLS) or the training data of the task-related corpus . This semantic-based tokenisation approach enhances the understanding of clinical text by incorporating domain-specific knowledge into the tokenisation process.
-
Improved Performance: The K-Tokeniser demonstrates improved performance in various clinical Natural Language Processing (NLP) tasks compared to existing models. For instance, in automated clinical coding tasks, the K-Tokeniser shows a notable 13% increase in the Micro F1 score, indicating enhanced accuracy and efficiency in processing clinical text data .
-
Efficiency in Training: The study reveals that language models using the K-Tokeniser require only 50% of the training data to achieve optimal performance compared to baseline tokenisers in concept extraction tasks and less than 20% of the data for automated coding tasks . This efficiency in training data utilization can lead to quicker convergence of language models, reducing the computational resources required for training.
-
Fertility-Based Analysis: The paper explores the correlation between word fertility and F1 scores in clinical concept extraction tasks, highlighting a relationship between the variation in fertility and corresponding differences in F1 scores. By setting fertility thresholds at specific values, such as 0.035 and 0.065, the K-Tokeniser optimizes performance based on word characteristics .
-
Evaluation Methodology: The study conducts a comprehensive set of experiments on real-world datasets to assess the performance of the K-Tokeniser in clinical text analytics tasks, including clinical concept and relation extraction, automated clinical coding, clinical phenotype identification, and clinical research article classification . These experiments demonstrate consistent improvements over existing models, showcasing the effectiveness of the K-Tokeniser in various clinical NLP applications.
Overall, the K-Tokeniser stands out for its semantic-based tokenisation approach, improved performance in clinical NLP tasks, efficiency in training data utilization, fertility-based optimization, and rigorous evaluation methodology, making it a valuable advancement in enhancing the processing of clinical text data .
Do any related researches exist? Who are the noteworthy researchers on this topic in this field?What is the key to the solution mentioned in the paper?
Several related research studies exist in the field of infusing clinical knowledge into tokenisers for language models. One notable study introduces a novel knowledge-enhanced tokenisation mechanism called K-Tokeniser for clinical text processing . The researchers involved in this study include Abul Hasan, Jinge Wu, Quang Ngoc Nguyen, Salomé Andres, Imane Guellil, Huayu Zhang, Arlene Casey, Beatrice Alex, Bruce Guthrie, and Honghan Wu .
The key to the solution proposed in the paper involves the following components:
- Expanding Vocabulary: The K-Tokeniser expands the vocabulary of a baseline tokeniser by deriving global character representations based on semantic types of domain concepts from a domain ontology or task-specific corpus .
- Embedding Initialisation: A method is proposed to initialise embeddings of new subwords to transfer knowledge from a pre-trained model, utilizing its existing vocabulary .
- Optimisation Objectives: Two optimisation objectives are integrated into the K-Tokeniser at the inference stage to discover the optimal subword representation by considering both global semantic representations of medical concepts and localised context at the sentence level .
- Performance Improvement: The study demonstrates consistent improvements over their counterparts in various clinical text analytics tasks, with substantial enhancements observed in automated clinical coding tasks and quicker convergence of language models using K-Tokeniser .
How were the experiments in the paper designed?
The experiments in the paper were designed to evaluate the performance of the K-Tokeniser in various clinical text analytics tasks using transformer-based language models on real-world datasets. The experiments involved:
- Conducting a comprehensive set of experiments on four real-world datasets to evaluate K-Tokeniser in clinical text analytics tasks such as clinical concept and relation extraction, automated clinical coding, clinical phenotype identification, and clinical research article classification .
- Comparing the performance of K-ClinicalBERT, K-PubMedBERT, and K-Bioformer models against their baseline counterparts (ClinicalBERT, PubMedBERT, and Bioformer) on smaller training set sizes by partitioning the training data into increments of 20%, 30%, 50%, and 100% .
- Demonstrating that models constructed using the K-Tokeniser consistently outperformed their baseline models across all training data sizes and tasks, with significant improvements observed in automated clinical coding tasks and clinical concept extraction .
- Showing that models built using the K-Tokeniser achieved the baseline model's accuracy using only 20% of the training data in tasks like ICD-9 clinical coding, indicating faster convergence and reduced computing resources without the need for expensive pre-training .
What is the dataset used for quantitative evaluation? Is the code open source?
The dataset used for quantitative evaluation in the study on infusing clinical knowledge into tokenisers for language models is the n2c2 corpus, which is a benchmark dataset for clinical concepts and relation extraction . The code for the study is not explicitly mentioned to be open source in the provided context.
Do the experiments and results in the paper provide good support for the scientific hypotheses that need to be verified? Please analyze.
The experiments and results presented in the paper provide strong support for the scientific hypotheses that needed verification. The study introduces a novel knowledge-enhanced tokenisation mechanism called K-Tokeniser for clinical text processing, which aims to improve various clinical Natural Language Processing (NLP) tasks . The experiments conducted using three transformer-based language models on real-world datasets demonstrate consistent improvements over their counterparts in tasks such as clinical concept and relation extraction, automated clinical coding, clinical phenotype identification, and clinical research article classification . The results show substantial enhancements, particularly in the automated clinical coding task, with a notable 13% increase in Micro F1 score .
Furthermore, the study reveals that the K-Tokeniser approach facilitates quicker convergence of language models, requiring only 50% of the training data to achieve the best performance of the baseline tokeniser in certain tasks . This efficiency in training data utilization is a significant advantage and supports the hypothesis that the K-Tokeniser can enhance the performance of language models while reducing the data requirements . Additionally, the experiments compare the performance between models using the K-Tokeniser from the UMLS ontology and those constructed with corresponding BERT tokenisers across various training sizes, demonstrating the effectiveness of the K-Tokeniser approach .
Overall, the results obtained from the experiments provide robust evidence supporting the effectiveness and efficiency of the K-Tokeniser in improving clinical text processing tasks, validating the scientific hypotheses put forth in the study .
What are the contributions of this paper?
The paper "Infusing clinical knowledge into tokenisers for language models" presents several key contributions:
- Introduction of a novel tokenisation mechanism called K-Tokenisation designed specifically for clinical text processing, which expands the vocabulary of a baseline tokeniser by deriving global character representations from drug and symptom-related concepts extracted from domain ontologies or task-specific corpora .
- Proposal of a simple yet effective method for initialising embeddings of new subwords to transfer knowledge from pre-trained models, utilizing existing vocabularies .
- Integration of two optimization objectives into the K-Tokeniser at the inference stage, aiming to discover the optimal subword representation by considering both global semantic representations of medical concepts and localized context at the sentence level .
- Demonstrated improvements in various clinical text analytics tasks, including clinical concept and relation extraction, automated clinical coding, clinical phenotype identification, and clinical research article classification, with consistent enhancements observed over their counterparts in all tasks, particularly notable in the automated clinical coding task with a 13% increase in Micro F1 score .
What work can be continued in depth?
Further research in the field of clinical text processing can delve deeper into the following areas based on the study "Infusing clinical knowledge into tokenisers for language models":
- Exploration of Tokenisation Algorithms: Future work can focus on refining and optimizing the tokenisation algorithms used in clinical text processing to enhance the representation of words and subwords, especially in the context of clinical concepts and medical terminology .
- Integration of Global and Local Optimisation Objectives: Research can continue to explore the integration of global semantic representations of medical concepts and localised context at the sentence level to further improve the tokenisation process and enhance language model capabilities in clinical text analytics tasks .
- Evaluation of Different Training Data Sizes: Further investigation can be conducted to evaluate the performance of models constructed using the K-Tokeniser across various training data sizes to understand the impact on different clinical tasks, such as automated clinical coding and clinical concept extraction, and to optimize the training process for efficiency and effectiveness .